the news site for journalists covering development issues

Forecasters 'warned of Horn of Africa drought' last year

The drought is the worst in 60 years, according to the UN. Photo: Flickr/Oxfam International[LONDON] Forecasting systems were warning about a serious drought in the Horn of Africa as much as a year ago — but communication problems between scientists and decision-makers meant the alerts went largely unheeded, according to forecasters.

Warnings about the drought — which the United Nations says is the worst in 60 years — were issued last August, when the Famine Early Warning Systems Network (FEWS NET) released a brief on food security in East Africa following the declaration of a La Niña event, a cooling of the sea surface in the Pacific Ocean known to affect weather in Africa.

"We were very confident that the October to December rains were going to be poor," Chris Hillbruner, a food security early warning specialist with FEWS NET, told SciDev.Net. "And there was an increased likelihood that the March to May rains were going to be poor as well."

Once the predictions for October–December proved correct, the agency started releasing food security alerts for the region in November, February, March, May and June, and organising multiagency meetings in Nairobi, in February, March and May.

The drought is now affecting ten million people in Djibouti, Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia and Uganda.

Chris Funk, a climatologist with FEWS NET, said that the organisation's experts have been "a little frustrated that we provided this information quite early" but not enough has been done to make good use of it.

"The technology has outpaced the response systems," he said. "We are still developing rapid response capability around that."

And Hillbruner added: "At the technical level, there's been agreement about the situation for the past five months.

"What we've demonstrated over time, but particularly in the last year, is that systems have got to the point where they can do pretty good early warning within a timeframe that offers opportunities for response."

Randolph Kent, director of the Humanitarian Futures Program at the UK's King's College London, said that the drought response raised issues about how the humanitarian community turns scientific information and uncertain predictions into decisions about a response, particularly in turbulent regions.

His comments were supported by Molly Hellmuth, a researcher at the International Research Institute for Climate and Society at Columbia University in the United States, who co-edited a report about mitigating weather disasters, published last month in Climate and Society.

Hellmuth said clearer forecasts are needed that are aimed at decision-makers and come with recommended action steps stating what levels and types of action would be a sensible response.

And some 'no regrets' actions that may not have a negative effect even if the predictions do not come true could be encouraged — such as repositioning of food supplies and capacity building, she said.

Hillbruner agreed that the uncertainties in forecasting hamper its use: "In order to use early warning information most effectively, decision-makers have to be comfortable with that uncertainty — and it's difficult to be comfortable with it."

But Funk added that the monitoring systems used for forecasting are now playing a powerful role in the huge humanitarian response now underway, making it a much more effective response than that to the Ethiopian famine in 1984–5.

Simon Mason, who works with Hellmuth, said that his research has shown that both forecasters and the end-users have a fear of being proved 'wrong' which causes all players to dilute their predictions and actions.

In a recent assessment of early warning systems, which did not include the FEWS NET Horn of Africa drought forecasts, Mason found that forecasters are "playing safe; being very reluctant to issue strong warnings of severe climate events even when their models are suggesting there is a high chance of more extreme conditions".

Hillbruner, however, denied that this had been the case with the Horn of Africa drought predictions.

In the humanitarian community, Andrew Collodel, an emergency programme coordinator with the aid agency HelpAge International agreed that the forecasts had been made and communicated. HelpAge had listened to early warnings and worked in the region to prepare for the drought, but it had failed to garner sufficient funds in advance of the crisis.

Donors had faced "confounding issues" such as the global financial situation, troubled local politics such as the chaotic situation in Somalia, and several other recent major crises that had raided their resources, such as the one following the Haiti earthquake and the tsunami in Japan.

"The early warning systems are not a problem, how we react to them is," he told SciDev.Net.

Link to FEWS NET's initial August 2010 brief on food security in East Africa [219kB]

Link to full 'A Better Climate for Disasters Risk Management' [5.98MB]

Source: Visit SciDev.Net

Get the World News and Media Diary

World News and Media Diary

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 87

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 96

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 87

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 96

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 87

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 96

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 87

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 96

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 87

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 96

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 87

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/worlda8/public_html/components/com_eventlist/helpers/route.php on line 96

Gender-based violence in Sierra Leone

Freetown Rainbo Centre staffRainbo Centre signWorking to prevent violence
Midwife Annie MafindaSafiatu Jalloh, counselorMidwife Many Sowa
Rakel LarsonChief Officer Balogun DixonMadam Julia Sarkodie Mensah
Police Family Support UnitCourtroom posterJoseph Rahall

Freetown Rainbo Centre staff

Staff, including midwives, counsellors and security guards, at the Freetown Rainbo Centre, in the Princeses Christian Maternity Hospital, which deals with rape crises. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Rainbo Centre sign

Rainbo Centre sign which hangs in all three centres in Sierra Leone. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Working to prevent violence

Six members of a men's group in Kenema, Sierra Leone run by IRC. They are working to change men's attitudes and stop violence before it starts. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Midwife Annie Mafinda

Midwife Annie Mafinda, with toys in the counselling room at the Freetown Rainbo Centre. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Safiatu Jalloh, counselor

Safiatu Jalloh, counselor with the Rainbo Centre in Kenema. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Midwife Many Sowa

Many Sowa, midwife at the Kenema Rainbo Centre, Sierra Leone. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Rakel Larson

Rakel Larson, United Nations Displaced Persons representative, working with Irish Aid on the Saturday Courts project. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Chief Officer Balogun Dixon

Balogun Dixon, Chief Officer Pademba Road Prison, at the Freetown Courthouse. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Madam Julia Sarkodie Mensah

Madam Julia Sarkodie Mensah, Consultant Master and Registrar of the Sierra Leone Judiciary. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Police Family Support Unit

The Family Support Unit in the Kenema Police Force, pictured outside their station. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Courtroom poster

Poster on the walls of a courtroom in the Freetown Courthouse building offering socio-legal support for victims of gender-based violence. Photo: Niamh Griffin.

Joseph Rahall

Joseph Rahall, Executive Director of eco-NGO 'Green Scenery', at their offices in Freetown, Sierra Leone.